Best Criminal Defence Lawyer - Karapancev Law
Close this search box.
Close this search box.

Understanding Extradition: A Guide for Canadians

Extradition is a significant legal process that involves the transfer of an alleged criminal from one country to another. This process is especially relevant for Canadians, as it affects those accused of crimes abroad. If you find yourself in such a situation, it’s crucial to know your rights and understand how the extradition process works.

What is Extradition?

Extradition occurs when one country requests another to surrender an alleged criminal. This process is governed by specific legal frameworks and treaties between countries. In Canada, extradition is only considered if the alleged offence is also a crime under Canadian law.

Facing extradition challenges? Call Alex Karapancev at (416) 613-9984 for expert legal guidance.

The Canadian Extradition Process

The extradition process in Canada involves three critical stages:

  1. Authority to Proceed: The Minister of Justice decides whether to start extradition proceedings by issuing an ‘Authority to Proceed’.
  2. Judicial Phase: The courts determine if there’s sufficient evidence for extradition.
  3. Ministerial Phase: The Minister of Justice personally decides on the surrender of the individual to the foreign state.

Criteria for Extradition

  • Bilateral Treaties: Canada must have an extradition treaty with the requesting country.
  • Dual Criminality: The act must be a crime in both countries.
  • Human Rights Considerations: Canada will not extradite if the death penalty is a possible outcome in the requesting country.

Don’t navigate extradition alone. For professional assistance, reach out to Alex Karapancev at (416) 613-9984.

Legal Implications and Your Rights

If facing extradition, understanding your legal rights is crucial. You may be eligible for bail during the extradition process. The court will assess the risk of committing further crimes or fleeing. Legal counsel is indispensable in these situations. Experienced criminal lawyers can guide you through the process, potentially help prevent extradition, and secure legal representation for you in the requesting country.

Can Extradition Orders be Appealed?

Yes, extradition orders can be appealed, including seeking judicial review of the Minister’s decision. The process may extend to the Supreme Court of Canada. Only after the final judgement of the appeal court does the extradition process commence.

Grounds for Refusal of Extradition

The Minister of Justice can refuse extradition based on various grounds, including if it’s deemed unjust, oppressive, or discriminatory. Political offences and military offences not recognized under criminal law are also grounds for refusal.

Secure your rights in extradition cases. Connect with Alex Karapancev at (416) 613-9984 for skilled legal representation.

Frequently Asked Questions

What countries have extradition treaties with Canada?

Canada has extradition treaties with numerous countries, including the United States, United Kingdom, France, Germany, India, and more.

  • Albania, Argentina, Austria
  • Belgium, Bolivia
  • Chile, Colombia, Cuba, Czechoslovakia,
  • Denmark
  • Ecuador, El Salvador, Estonia
  • Finland, France
  • Germany, Greece, Guatemala
  • Haiti, Hong Kong, Hungary
  • Iceland, India, Israel, Italy
  • Korea
  • Latvia, Liberia, Lithuania, Luxembourg,
  • Mexico, Monaco
  • Netherlands, Nicaragua, Norway
  • Panama, Paraguay, Peru, Philippines, Portugal,
  • Romania
  • San Marino, South Africa, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland
  • Thailand
  • United States, Uruguay

Which countries do not have extradition treaties with Canada (abbreviated)?

  • Russia, China, and Mongolia.
  • Brunei.
  • The Gulf States.
  • Montenegro, Serbia. 
  • Eastern Europe: Ukraine and Moldova.
  • South-East Asia: Vietnam, Cambodia, and Laos.
  • Island Nations: Maldives, Vanuatu, and Indonesia.
  • Africa: Ethiopia, Botswana, and Tunisia.

Extradition Questions? Alex Karapancev is here to help. Call (416) 613-9984 for experienced legal support.

What happens if you are arrested pending extradition?

You may obtain bail from the Superior Court of Justice, where the judge assesses the risk of further crimes or fleeing before the extradition hearing.

Can the Minister of Justice deny an extradition order?

Yes, the Minister of Justice has the discretion to refuse extradition even after a judge orders it. This decision is based on factors outlined in the Extradition Act, such as the possibility of an unjust or oppressive outcome, discrimination based on race, religion, nationality, or other factors, and whether the offence is considered political.

Extradition and Immigration Prosecutions

It’s important to note that extradition processes can sometimes intersect with immigration issues. If you’re involved in immigration proceedings, understanding how extradition might impact your status is vital.

With a deep understanding of the intricacies of extradition law, experienced extradition lawyers such as Nicholas Robinson are well-equipped to provide you with the support and advice you need during this challenging time.

Alexander Karapancev

Alexander Karapancev

Alexander Karapancev is a Toronto criminal lawyer practicing throughout the province of Ontario. He regularly serves as lead trial counsel on serious and complex criminal cases. He is the founder of Karapancev Law, a law firm representing clients facing criminal charges, regulatory offences, and professional discipline proceedings.

Mr. Karapancev has acted as counsel in hundreds of cases throughout the province of Ontario, regularly representing clients at trials, applications, bail hearings and preliminary inquiries. He is regularly retained to defend individuals charged with serious allegations of fraud, drug trafficking, DUI offences, domestic assault, and sexual assault. Prior to founding his law firm, Mr. Karapancev practiced criminal defence at a boutique Toronto law firm and also served as a per diem Crown prosecutor.

Top Rated Toronto Criminal Defence Lawyers

Results matter. A reputation built on winning. Karapancev Law Is Ready to Fight for You!